Because MVP is a reporting path within MIPS rather than a separate program, the "pros and cons" are really about which path fits your practice, not whether to participate in MIPS at all.

Traditional MIPS gives you the most flexibility — you can hand-pick individual measures from a large menu to play to your practice's strengths, which works well for large, multi-specialty groups with the staff to manage that selection. The tradeoff is the administrative load: choosing, tracking, and documenting a custom set of measures each year, many of which may have little clinical relevance to what your clinicians actually do.

MVP trades that flexibility for focus. You report a smaller, pre-built set of measures, one improvement activity, and a cost measure built around your specialty or condition — which cuts the guesswork, aligns reporting with your actual clinical workflow, and benchmarks you against similar specialists rather than the whole MIPS population. The tradeoffs: less room to strategically select easier measures, an upfront lift to align your EHR and registry workflows to the new measure set, and not every specialty has a fully mature MVP built yet.

The Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS) is one way healthcare providers can participate in the Quality Payment Program (QPP) established by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). MIPS is one way to participate in the Quality Payment Program (QPP).

MIPS combines three previously separate quality and value reporting programs into a single, streamlined system:

Physician Quality Reporting System (PQRS)

Value-Based Modifier (VBM)

Electronic Health Record (EHR) Meaningful Use program

MIPS was created through the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015 (MACRA), which was designed to change how Medicare rewards clinicians for value over volume. MACRA created the Quality Payment Program that repeals the Sustainable Growth Rate formula, changes the way that Medicare rewards clinicians for value over volume, and streamlines multiple quality programs under MIPS.

MIPS Value Pathways (MVP) is a streamlined, specialty-focused way to report under MIPS. Instead of picking from hundreds of unrelated quality measures, you report a smaller, pre-built set of measures, activities, and a cost measure aligned to your specialty or condition — cardiology, oncology, orthopedics, and so on. MVPs still use the same four MIPS performance categories and the same scoring and payment-adjustment structure as traditional MIPS; it's a different path through the same program, not a separate program.

MVP reporting is currently optional. That's likely to change: in the CY 2027 Physician Fee Schedule proposed rule, CMS proposed sunsetting traditional MIPS reporting after the CY 2028 performance period, which would make MVP reporting the only MIPS reporting option starting with the CY 2029 performance period (2031 payment year) for clinicians not in an Advanced APM.

Some healthcare providers may be exempt from MIPS reporting requirements, including:

Newly-enrolled Medicare providers

Qualifying participants in Advanced Alternative Payment Models (APMs)

and

Providers who don't exceed the low-volume threshold:

Billing less than $90,000 in allowed charges for covered professional services under the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule and

Providing care to fewer than 200 Medicare Part B beneficiaries and

Furnishing fewer than 200 covered professional services under the Physician Fee Schedule

The Ambulatory Specialty Model (ASM) isn't a MIPS reporting option — it's a separate, mandatory CMS payment model that holds specific specialists financially accountable for managing two chronic condition areas: heart failure and low back pain.

You have to participate if you're a cardiologist treating heart failure, or an anesthesiologist, pain management specialist, neurosurgeon, orthopedic surgeon, or physical medicine/rehabilitation clinician treating low back pain — and you practice in one of CMS's selected metropolitan areas, having treated at least 20 Original Medicare patients with the relevant condition over a 12-month period. If you meet those criteria, there's no opting out, regardless of how you report MIPS or MVP for everything else. Performance years run 2027 through 2031, with payment adjustments of -9% to +9%, budget-neutral across all participants.

Check your ASM Status with Us